A Jack of All Trades is a Master of None, But?

In an AI-driven job market, people who connect ideas across domains – generalists – are becoming far more valuable than narrow technical experts.

‘A jack of all trades is the master of none’ is most certainly a saying you’ve come across at some point in your life, designed to mean that someone who does many things cannot truly excel at any one of them. It is usually offered as a warning: pick a lane, specialize, go deep or risk mediocrity.

Walk into any MBA classroom and you will hear the same advice. Pick a domain. Build depth. Become the expert. And for years, that made sense. Companies hired finance experts for finance, marketers for marketing, coders for coding. The deeper you went, the more secure you were.

But did you know the full version of the saying is actually ‘A jack of all trades is a master of none, but oftentimes better than a master of one’? The forgotten second half flips the meaning on its head. It suggests that breadth, when paired with competence, can be more powerful than narrow mastery alone.

The job market is noting a similar shift. According to LinkedIn’s Global Talent Trends report, skills needed for jobs have changed by around 25% since 2015. By 2027, that number is expected to double. The World Economic Forum estimates that 44% of workers’ skills will be disrupted in the next few years.

When skills change that quickly, pure specialization becomes risky. The market now rewards people who can adapt, connect and translate across domains. In other words, generalists are quietly making a comeback. 

How does a Generalist role look today?

A generalist does not mean someone who knows a little about everything and nothing properly.

A modern generalist has one solid foundation but can operate across adjacent areas. Think of someone who understands finance but can also use Excel dashboards, build a basic model in Python, present insights clearly and collaborate with product teams.

Imagine two entry-level analysts. One knows advanced financial ratios by heart but struggles to explain them or use modern tools. The other knows core finance, can pull data into Power BI, uses ChatGPT to summarize earnings calls and explains insights in simple slides. Who is more valuable in a fast-moving team?

Companies increasingly prefer the second profile. McKinsey has reported that demand for technological, social and higher cognitive skills is rising sharply. Employers want people who combine technical literacy with communication and problem solving.

This is the generalist edge. It is not about being average at everything. It is about connecting depth with breadth.

And while you might think this is a five-year-later problem, it most certainly is not.

Look at internships and entry-level roles today. A marketing intern is expected to analyze campaign data in Google Analytics. A finance trainee is expected to use Excel beyond basic formulas. A consulting intern is expected to clean messy data and build slides using insights from multiple sources.

AI tools have accelerated this shift. Software like ChatGPT, Notion AI and Copilot can handle routine tasks. They can draft emails, summarize reports and even generate basic code. This means companies need fewer people doing repetitive work. Instead, they need people who can ask the right questions, interpret outputs and connect dots across teams. AI is taking over narrow tasks. Humans are becoming integrators.

If you only know how to do one tightly defined task, you compete with automation. If you understand context, strategy and tools across functions, you become harder to replace. That is why generalists are gaining importance. They can adapt when one tool changes or one function shrinks. 

The New Data Analyst

Suppose you join a startup as a business analyst. Your job description says “data analysis.” In reality, you will:

● Pull data from Excel or Google Sheets

● Clean it using formulas or basic Python

● Use ChatGPT to draft summaries

● Create visualizations in Power BI or Tableau

● Present insights to non-technical managers

No one will say, “Please only analyze and do nothing else.” Early-career roles are messy by design.

Even in large firms, cross-functional collaboration is increasing. According to Deloitte, organizations are moving toward more team-based structures rather than rigid hierarchies. That means you sit with tech, marketing and operations in the same project.

The person who can speak a bit of each language becomes extremely valuable. So what should you actually do?

First, build one strong core. If you are a finance major, understand financial statements deeply. If you are into marketing, understand consumer behavior properly. Breadth without depth is weak.

Second, add adjacent skills deliberately. Learn Excel well. Not basic SUM formulas, but pivot tables and data cleaning. Get comfortable with at least one visualization tool like Power BI. Explore basic Python for data manipulation. You do not need to be a coder. You need to be tool-literate.

Third, learn to work with AI tools. Practice giving clear prompts. Use ChatGPT to brainstorm, summarize articles, or improve presentations. The skill is not copying outputs. It is knowing how to guide the tool.

Fourth, communicate clearly. Many technically strong graduates struggle because they cannot explain their thinking. Practice turning data into simple stories. If your grandmother cannot understand your explanation, simplify it.

Finally, stay curious. Read outside your specialization. If you are in finance, follow product launches. If you are in marketing, read about supply chains. Cross-pollination builds range.

The world is not abandoning specialists. Surgeons still need deep expertise. Quant traders still need advanced mathematics. But for most business roles, especially early in your career, range is becoming power.

If skills are changing every few years, your real asset is not a narrow toolkit. It is the ability to learn, connect and reapply knowledge across contexts. In a world obsessed with expertise, the quiet advantage belongs to those who can connect the dots.

#Careers #AI #PraxisBusinessSchool #FutureOfWork #Upskilling #MBAStudents